Best Place for an Oil Change – Without Being Ripped Off

There are many options of where to go when it’s time to get your car’s oil changed, including dealers, general repair shops, chain repair shops and “quick lube” shops that specialize in oil changes. Picking the right one is a matter of balancing convenience, quality and cost.

Keeping on top of your car’s maintenance schedule is critical to the life of your engine, and ignoring it could cost you dearly when the added wear and tear catches up with the motor’s internal components. However, there’s often a difference between the services you’re offered and the services you actually need. What should you do if the shop says you need a new air filter or have the radiator flushed? What type of oil should you ask for? What services and add-ons are useful, and which should you pass on?

In This Guide

Comparing Shops & Prices

Many people will choose a shop strictly on the price of the service, but that’s not always the best idea. While the advertised price may be low, there can be a lot of hidden charges that result in a final bill that’s much higher than you planned on. Call ahead and get an estimate so you know what you’ll be dealing with.

Some consideration also needs to be made to the oil being used. Many new cars require synthetic oil, and there are some vehicles that even have different intervals depending on the oil used. For example, in some engines, Toyota recommends getting a change every 5,000 miles with conventional oil, or 10,000 miles if synthetic oil and a high quality filter are used.

While the synthetic oil may be more expensive up front, it may save you money in the long run thanks to less frequent service. Unless specifically stated, advertised prices for oil changes are for conventional oil.

Where Should I Get My Oil Changed?

oil-changeHow much service do you want when you have it done? A dealer or general repair shop will usually do a detailed inspection of your vehicle while it’s being serviced, and they may find issues before they become major repair problems.

If you just want your oil swapped out, there are plenty of national auto shops that specialize in quick, affordable service:

  • Express Oil
  • Goodyear
  • Jiffy Lube
  • NTB
  • Pep Boys
  • Valvoline
  • Walmart

Some shops offer other maintenance services, while others only do oilchanges or other fluid-related services like radiator and transmission flushes.

Read Reviews

The level and quality of service can vary widely from shop to shop, so it’s a good idea to read customer reviews to find out what you can expect to experience if you bring your vehicle in. This includes local chain stores, as many use a franchise system with different owners, and even corporate-owned locations can vary depending on the managers and technicians they employ.

What to Consider

Is your vehicle under warranty?
In many cases, the manufacturer’s warranty will include services like oil changes free of charge at dealerships, particularly for luxury brands. If it’s not covered, then you can usually save a lot of money by steering clear of dealers.

Is your car an import or exotic?
If your vehicle is rare or built to a very high level of performance, it’s best to take it to a shop that specializes in such vehicles. Some of these vehicles require specialized tools and methods, so it pays to have work done by technicians prepared to work on them.

How many miles do you drive each year?
Even though using a high quality synthetic is more expensive compared to a conventional oil, it may be worthwhile just so you don’t have to get your car serviced as frequently.

What to Ask For

extra-services-with-oil-changeYou’re looking for a “basic oil change” which should just include changing the oil, oil filter, and maybe an oil plug seal. You should only upgrade to a different types of oil or filters if you think they’re necessary.

Extra services included with the service like a tire pressure check are fine, but you are not required to pay for additional services. If the technician does find a possible issue, it’s up to you to decide if you want the shop to address it, do the servicing yourself, or have it fixed at another shop.

When They Ask You to Buy Other Stuff

Air Filters
How long an air filter lasts depends on the design of your car’s intake. Some models only last 9,000 miles, while other can go 30,000 miles or more. A little visible dirt is normal and does not mean it need to be changed.

Cabin Filter
The cabin filter removes contaminants from air going through the HVAC system before it goes through the fan and interior vents. This filter is usually located behind the glove box and can be removed without tools. Check the owner’s manual for the correct procedure: this is one job you may want to tackle yourself. Like air filters, the life of a cabin filter can vary depending on the design, from 10,000 to 30,000 miles.

Transmission Fluid
Depending on the transmission, the fluid may need to be changed every 60,000 miles, or it could be designed to last the lifetime of the vehicle. Some new “sealed” transmissions don’t even have a replaceable filter. Do your research before saying yes to a transmission flush. If you have a CVT, it’s extremely important that the correct fluid is used and it’s filled to the right level to prevent overheating. When in doubt, have this service performed by a dealer.

Like oil and transmission fluid, coolant lasts much longer than it used to, sometimes as long as 150,000 miles or 5 years. Make sure your car actually needs a radiator flush before signing off on one.

Windshield Wipers
Only buy new standard wiper blades if they don’t move smoothly across the windshield when it’s raining. Switching to winter blades may be a good idea if you live in an area with heavy snow fall because they’re built to resist ice build up. Changing wiper blades is fairly simple, so you may want to do this yourself.

Windshield Wiper Fluid
Adding windshield wiper fluid is even easier than changing the cabin filter: just open the hood, find the cap labeled with a wiper symbol, open it, pour in the fluid, and close the lid. With fluid available for a couple bucks a gallon and at almost any parts store, discount store and grocery store, you don’t even have to go out of the way to buy it.

How Often Does Oil Need to Be Changed?

Some quick change oil shops push for oil changes every 3,000 miles, but modern engines have intervals ranging from 5,000 to 15,000 miles, and some even have oil sensors that tell you when the oil needs to be changed. Go by the recommendations of the manufacturer in your owner’s manual, not the shop.

What to Read Next

Over to You

We’re interested to know – where did you get your last oil change done and what was your experience like? Let other readers know by leaving a comment below!

Let us know your thoughts

4 thoughts on “Best Place for an Oil Change – Without Being Ripped Off

  1. I had my oil changed on my 2000 Jeep Grand Cherokee at Jiffy Lube on Blackwood Clementon Rd in Blackwood, NJ. They did nothing except change my oil. No filter. They said they checked my SUV over. Recommended a couple of things but I said “no”. I do know a little bit about cars. They were minor and I could do it myself. When they finished trying to get me to get more services, I asked for my total. I almost died! My bill was $75+. I guess I should’ve checked around for prices before I had it changed. My late husband always didn’t it. After that price, I thought I should check around. Apparently, I was ripped off! Jiffy Lube is supposed to have a good reputation for fair prices that’s why I went there. Didn’t think twice about it. Can’t trust anyone now a days! Well, I guess I have to chalk it up as “Live and learn”.

  2. Basic oil change includes oil, filter, and LUBE.

    Don’t forget lube. People like to wave their hand in the air and say “everything uses lubed for life bearings”. NO! Many manufacturers started using these sealed bearings decades ago, but that is not a valid reason to assume everything did.

    Even years ago, I had to check that an oil change place had done the lube because often they didn’t, on vehicles that came stock with parts that needed it. Add to that, many people prefer the parts like ball joints that have metal bushings that need lubed when it comes time to replace them, especially in areas subject to potholes which more easily damage the sealed BJs that use a plastic bushing.

    Something to request at an oil change place is “don’t touch anything else”, do not check my power steering level, do not check my brake fluid, or air filter, etc. I don’t want some grunt breaking things while fishing to up-sell more services and the rate of them breaking things is higher than you might suspect because those gorillas muscle off and yank out without much concern for what they might break, then 9 times out of 10 they won’t tell you they broke something, like the latches on your air filter box so its just bouncing around with air sucked in past the filter and you can’t just buy latches for your filter box, it is an assembly that is crazy expensive for what it is, if you don’t DIY pull a used one at a junkyard or device an alternate method of fastening it down.

    Short version: Don’t let anyone touch your vehicle any more than absolutely necessary.